Give the pecan pie some love!

I do not ever remember seeing pecan pie on the menu. :( :mad: And I love pecan pie.

I don't remember seeing it on the menu either. Is it on the "regular old menu" or on the new American Table menu?

Just checked the American Table dessert menu that I printed out last year and see that pie is offered every night, but it doesn't say what kind. I know it was a different kind every night, though.

I don't remember seeing it on the menu either. Is it on the "regular old menu" or on the new American Table menu?

 

Old menu, see day 5

http://www.zydecocruiser.net/CarnivalLegend/menus/dinner1-6.html

Just checked my 7 day menus and pecan pie is not on then. It must be on longer sailings only :(

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

This is what I show for the current day 5 menu.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

This is what I show for the current day 5 menu.

 

 

 

 

 

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

We had that dessert menu on day 10 of our 12 day (The same one where pecan was day 5)...they must mix them up a bit.

I have been on 30 cruises and have never seen pecan pie on the menu. It's my favorite, so I know I would have ordered it. I hope they will add it.:D

Oh how I love pecan pie. I never saw it on the menu on the Magic.

It looks like that Day 5 menu from zydecocruiser was on a cruise in Europe. I don't remember seeing it on any of the Caribbean cruises I have been on.

Sharon

I have never seen that menu.

I would like to see that menu though.

Just been reading a few food threads and see lots of discussion on how bitter and blanc and WCMC are wonderful and how the baked alaska and pumpkin pie are horrible.

 

However I never see anyone mention my favourite Carnival MDR dessert....the pecan pie!

 

Anyone else love this dessert or is it just me?

 

I've never had a pecan pie that is as good as mine. It's gotta be good southern pecan pie for me to eat it. Is it that good-like southern pecan pie good??

Yummy! I would definitely order that if I had seen it, but don't ever recall seeing it on the menu.

It was always available on the longer Transatlantic cruises.

However, not as good as it used to be. It used to be all gooey and caramelly (sp)

I don't bother to order it any more as last few times too dry.

We have two longer cruises coming up and hopefully will see it than.

We do 4-5 cruises a year and have never seen it offered. 14 day Panama Canal a no go too. But if it has the hint of orange I probably would be out anyway, but would sure give it a try once to check it out!

Kat

We had that dessert menu on day 10 of our 12 day (The same one where pecan was day 5)...they must mix them up a bit.

I agree, would love to see this dessert menu. Would have the Amaretto cake, Baked Alaska, and Cheesecake for dessert (yes, on the same night. :) )

I agree, would love to see this dessert menu. Would have the Amaretto cake, Baked Alaska, and Cheesecake for dessert (yes, on the same night. :) )

Sorry there is a rule on CCL that if you get three desserts one must be the WCMC.

Well, if I must say, that is a "silly rule".... And I've always been one to test the "edges" of the rules. :)

I am also a big fan of Pecan Pie, but Key Lime Pie is my fav!! Seems that KLP has been relegated to the lido desert buffet only once each cruise at lunch. Consequently, I tend to miss it. :(

Nothing wrong with having 3 desserts!

As a Brit I must say pecan pie isnt often on the menu but it s a little like English treacle tart with pecans in. As a massive fan of nuts I love it. Carnival's offering reminds me of a fairly yummy treacle tart with nuts in.

Sad to hear it wasn't on the Panama Canal cruise earlier this year....I was hoping to have it next month on the Legend 13 day voyage.

If its there I am having 2 pieces! :D

yes, 2... a warm pecan pie and vanilla ice cream :)

I am also a big fan of Pecan Pie, but Key Lime Pie is my fav!! Seems that KLP has been relegated to the lido desert buffet only once each cruise at lunch. Consequently, I tend to miss it. :(

As far as I can tell key lime pie has been only seen on lido the first day at sea. Best dessert they have.

Well, if I must say, that is a "silly rule".... And I've always been one to test the "edges" of the rules. :)

Actually the rule is kind of pie shaped when you get two slices of pie.:):)

Nothing wrong with having 3 desserts!

 

As a Brit I must say pecan pie isnt often on the menu but it s a little like English treacle tart with pecans in. As a massive fan of nuts I love it. Carnival's offering reminds me of a fairly yummy treacle tart with nuts in.

 

Sad to hear it wasn't on the Panama Canal cruise earlier this year....I was hoping to have it next month on the Legend 13 day voyage.

 

If its there I am having 2 pieces! :D

I wouldn't give up. I would expect to see it on a cruise of that length. Ask the maitre d' the first night if it will be served one evening, and if not, if they could prepare one for you. Sounds like it wouldn't be a problem for you to eat a pecan pie over a few evenings.

I LOVE pecan pie and have never seen it. :(

I don't ever remember seeing the pecan pie, but I'd never order it if I did see it. It is waaaaaaaaaaay too sweet for me. The only pie that Carnival has that I like is the Key Lime Pie, yum yum.