magic vs escape??

[MIsharona]

which cruise would you take?

[ColeThornton]

Not enough information provided to give you a good answer.

[CruiserBruce]

36 minutes ago, ColeThornton said:

Not enough information provided to give you a good answer.

Wow, no kidding. Cruise to where, when, itinerary...cabin level? Not enough info to give ANY answer.

[mom says]

And which Magic? Disney or Carnival? Come on, throw us something to go on.

[cruizergal70]

Ship doesn't matter. What's the itinerary?

[ColeThornton]

41 minutes ago, cruizergal70 said:

Ship doesn't matter. What's the itinerary?

 

 

The ship matters to many people for various reasons.  Curious as to why you think it doesn't?

[navybankerteacher]

1 hour ago, cruizergal70 said:

Ship doesn't matter. What's the itinerary?

Consider the Barberi - East coast home port, short itineraries, very low cost, no dress code.

Edited March 24, 2022 by navybankerteacher

[cruizergal70]

5 hours ago, ColeThornton said:

 

 

The ship matters to many people for various reasons.  Curious as to why you think it doesn't?

When I vacation,  I go to places. If I want to go to Aruba or Rome, I'll take whatever ship that's going there. The destination is my priority.  I would never make a decision based on ship.

[navybankerteacher]

5 hours ago, cruizergal70 said:

When I vacation,  I go to places. If I want to go to Aruba or Rome, I'll take whatever ship that's going there. The destination is my priority.  I would never make a decision based on ship.

If you really want to see Rome, do you think an eight hour port call - at a port at least an hour away (each way) - is the way to do it?  
 

If there was a great ship, with good food, service, and entertainment - and a grubby ship with little going for it, you would really “…never make a decision based on ship…”?

[mjkacmom]

14 hours ago, cruizergal70 said:

When I vacation,  I go to places. If I want to go to Aruba or Rome, I'll take whatever ship that's going there. The destination is my priority.  I would never make a decision based on ship.

But when you cruise, there is no guarantee that you will make it to any port. If I want a particular destination, I’ll take a land vacation.

[Aquahound]

Without any other info provided, I would recommend Escape.  I say that because I simply think Escape is a nicer ship than Magic....that is, if you're referring to Carnival Magic.  

 

Much more info is needed, though, for that to be a solid recommendation.

 

And yes, I most certainly agree that the ship and line matters.  Yes, destination is important, but this is a cruise vacation.  Therefore, the cruise matters too.   

[MIsharona]

celebration it is lol