Cookie Questions

[lennythenose]

I have two (admittedly silly) questions and both concern cookies.

 

1. Does anyone know what the plain brown cookies sprinkled with powdered sugar that they have on the buffet are? Too dark for sugar cookies...but oh so good! A friend called them "crack" cookies because they are so addictive.

 

2. On the Magic 12/27 cruise room service delivered us 2 plates of cookies on our last sea day that we did not order and we didn't have to sign for. I saw them being delivered to several rooms but have no idea why. Any thoughts?

 

As I said, questions of no true importance but they have been driving me crazy :D.

[freedomcruiser891]

I think it might be sad that this is my favorite thing about cruising (in general the food) but those cookies are seriously the best things in the world. I usually get at least one plateful a meal! I know room service has cookies you can get and you can also purchase cookies from fun shops pre order (the money goes to Saint Jude). I really want to know what kind they are though!

[edawn]

I don't remember having these so I'll have to check them out. My guess is that they're molasses cookies.

[mistycruiser]

I love those too and I'm not sure what they are either. To me they seem like a brown sugar, sugar cookie. But that's just a guess. I've had the casino deliver me plates of cookies but they usually come with a card so you know who sent them. Did you play in the casino during the trip?

Edited January 23, 2016 by mistycruiser

[sandij]

They're probably a molasses cookie their

version of a ginger snap, but my favorites are the chocolate chip, I always take a plate full back to my cabin after lunch to have late at night with hot chocolate.

Edited January 23, 2016 by sandij

[WAHMto5]

I think I could live on their chocolate chip ones!!

[lennythenose]

We didn't go to the casino abd thee was no card. They wetr yummy whioever sent them!

[Micahs Grandad]

I think I could live on their chocolate chip ones!!

 

They are super especially if you somehow get one fresh from the oven.

[skyeman27]

I think I could live on their chocolate chip ones!!

Soooo good ^^^^^^

[stargate fan]

I have two (admittedly silly) questions and both concern cookies.

 

1. Does anyone know what the plain brown cookies sprinkled with powdered sugar that they have on the buffet are? Too dark for sugar cookies...but oh so good! A friend called them "crack" cookies because they are so addictive.

 

2. On the Magic 12/27 cruise room service delivered us 2 plates of cookies on our last sea day that we did not order and we didn't have to sign for. I saw them being delivered to several rooms but have no idea why. Any thoughts?

 

As I said, questions of no true importance but they have been driving me crazy :D.

 

I think I could live on their chocolate chip ones!!

 

OMG, we call the chocolate chip cookies my "crack" as well. I enjoy them so much they are always part of my first meal on the ship, my last meal, heck every meal.

[mykindaparty]

I always bring a ziplock bag and load up on those cookies...to me they are like a sugar cookie vanilla wafer type... They make a really good vanilla pudding at home..hehehehe[emoji12]

[lennythenose]

I have tried wrapping in a napkin to rake to the room but they never stay fresh very long. Might have to take a ziplock next time.

[arby70]

The chocolate chip cookies are a lot of people's favorite. My last cruise I saw people with a plate piled so high they had to hold the cookies on the plate so they wouldn't fall off. I love 'em too, but not quite that much.;)

[funinthesun1964]

I'm not sure I've ever had these cookies. If you could compare them to a national package brand, how would you describe them? Or are they more like a homemade cookies? Are they more crunchy, or soft? I guess I have been missing out!

[Drazil65]

My DS gets an order of choco chip cookies and milk delivered to cabin every night, he loves them. If you order a double order they come in a little bag labeled "cookies" in what could be kids hands writing, cute.

 

OP maybe they delivered the cookies you got to wrong cabin by mistake, glad you enjoyed them!!!

[joeyancho]

My guess is peanut butter

[Frank12]

My guess is peanut butter

They are definitely not peanut butter. More like a sugar cookie made with brown sugar.

[leenieweenie]

Warning: Do not eat the chocolate chip cookies!!! Because you will not be able to stop!lol they are the best cookies,ever.

[MsSoloTravel]

I don't remember having cookies on my past cruises. Hmmm. I'm intrigued. I will add it to my to do list for Sept.

 

Are they soft or crunchy?

[cantw82cruise]

I think to me they are more like a butter cookie of some sort, they are really good. I love chocolate chip cookies but I'm not a huge fan of the ones on the buffet. The cookies they have at the bake shop are really good. We sometimes order a dozen delivered to the room to enjoy over the cruise.

[lizardhowson]

Interesting, because I consider myself a cookie conniseur of sorts and I was very disappointed by the cookies last week on Valor (dry and hard). Obviously I prefer soft cookies. I probably only ate 3 cookies the entire week.

[stargate fan]

I'm not sure I've ever had these cookies. If you could compare them to a national package brand, how would you describe them? Or are they more like a homemade cookies? Are they more crunchy, or soft? I guess I have been missing out!

 

The chocolate chip cookies do not compare to any brand. They are baked fresh every day and are crunchy and sweet with a slightly salty aftertaste.

Mmmm...only 27 more days to enjoy cookies!

[AXiDMonica]

THEIR CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES ARE THE GREATESTTTTTT!!!!! <33333333

 

That is all. ;):D

[SkyMaster]

I too, am addicted to the chocolate chip cookies, as I can't walk through the buffet area without snagging at least a couple of 'em. I'll have to give the others you're talking about a shot on my next cruise. They sound GREAT!

 

We too, get a plate of cookies delivered to the cabin occasionally, and when not accompanied with a card, I've always assumed it was because we're "Diamond", and also in the "Casino Club" group. :confused: In any case, they're a wonderful gift.

 

"SKY"

[Budget Queen]

Interesting, because I consider myself a cookie conniseur of sorts and I was very disappointed by the cookies last week on Valor (dry and hard). Obviously I prefer soft cookies. I probably only ate 3 cookies the entire week.

 

I agree- I don't find Carnival cookies very good. But, I am comparing to- quality, top ingredient made cookies, rich specialty chocolate, butter, no additives etc. :) They are just not to my liking. Everyone is different.