Have you ever done the exact same cruise on the exact same ship?

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 01:02 PM.
#1
Missouri
41 Posts
Joined Jan 2018
My wife/family and I enjoyed our last cruise so much. I told my wife that I'd love to book the exact same cruise (out of the exact same port, exact same ship, exact same stops) again later this year, and she said I was crazy. hah



For me....*shrug*....I kinda liked the idea? You'd be familiar with the ship, familiar with the stops and what not. I don't know. Have any of you ever done it multiple times and enjoyed it (or NOT enjoyed it?) Thoughts?
#2
1,781 Posts
Joined Jan 2012
I would do the Pride again and again and I hate the ports she stops at, but for me it is the ship, not the ports. The more sea days the better.
#3
VA
16,777 Posts
Joined Dec 2004
Out of what will be my 10th time on the Glory I have done them all multiple times. First 2 were a 5 day same itinerary. Next one was a little different - a 6 day. Then 4-10 have been the same Eastern or Western.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
If you have ANY questions, please contact me at firemanbobswife at ymail dot com. I'm always glad to help!
Carnival Conquest 12/2003, 1/2014, 8/2017
Carnival Valor 1/2005
Carnival Liberty 12/2007
Carnival Glory 5/2013, 10/2013, 5/2014, 10/2014, 5/2015, 12/2015, 2/2016, 10/2016, 10/2017, 4/2018

Carnival Vista 3/2017
Celebrity Solstice 12/2008, 12/2009
Celebrity Eclipse 12/2010, 12/2011
Celebrity Reflection 12/2012
#5
North Carolina
806 Posts
Joined Sep 2010
We've done the same ship twice now but yes I'd love to do the same ship and same cruise for the same reasons you mentioned.
Our first cruise was to Alaska (we live in North Carolina). I felt like we stumbled the whole time and I would love to do it again more prepared.
I have several friends who have done the same ports and same ship and they like it.
We are doing two of the same ports on our next cruise that we did last time. One is Cozumel. I want to do the exact same excursion there again (Mr. Sanchos) because I enjoyed it so much. I also want to catch Margaritaville OPEN since it was closed last time. I'm a trainer so I am always looking for lessons learned and I think that's why a second cruise appeals to me!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
November 2019: Cuba here we come on the Carnival Victory - yes #3 on the Victory!
August 2017: Carnival Victory review Miami/Key West/Cozumel: https://boards.cruisecritic.com/show....php?t=2537507
January 2011: Carnival Victory review/Southern Caribbean: http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showt...0156&highlight
May 2004: Carnival Fascination to the Bahamas
August 2002: Princess to Alaska
#7
South East Georgia
1,858 Posts
Joined Nov 2008
Yes, I've done the Fascination and Sensation numerous times since I am so close to each port.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Celebration June 1995 - High School Graduation
Carnival Glory June 2009 - First cruise of my husband and kids
Carnival Fascination Aug. 2010 http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showt...8061&highlight=
Carnival Sensation Jan. 2011
Carnival Fascination June 2, 2011 - Daughters bday cruise
Carnival Sensation Sept. 2012
Carnival Sensation April 2013
Carnival Fascination 2015
Carnival Victory September 2016
Carnival Valor April 2017 - Daughters last spring break as a high schooler
Carnival Paradise June 2018 - Daughters bday and first year of college done cruise https://boards.cruisecritic.com/show...9#post56286559
Carnival Liberty Sept 6
#8
Florida
131 Posts
Joined Mar 2015
Absolutely! I've done in multiple times.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Upcoming Cruises
11/03/18 - CCL Breeze: 14 Night Southern Caribbean
02/02/19 - CCL Breeze 7 Night Western Caribbean

Past Cruises
09/06/18 - CCL Liberty: 3 Night Bahamas
06/30/18 - CCL Magic: 7 Night Western Caribbean
05/05/18 - CCL Sunshine: 8 Night Eastern Caribbean
02/15/18 - CCL Liberty: 3 Night Bahamas
02/02/18 - CCL Sunshine: 8 Night Eastern Caribbean

11/18/17 - CCL Sunshine: 8 Night Southern Caribbean
10/12/17 - CCL Liberty: 3 Night Bahamas
08/31/17 - CCL Liberty: 3 Night Bahamas
06/29/17 - CCL Liberty: 3 Night Bahamas
04/15/17 - CCL Magic: 7 Night Western Caribbean
03/04/17 - CCL Sunshine: 8 Night Southern Caribbean

11/05/16 - CCL Magic: 7 Night Western Caribbean
06/25/16 - CCL Magic: 7 Night Eastern Caribbean
01/08/16 - Carnival Sunshine: 8 Night Eastern Caribbean

09/05/15 - CCL Valor: 7 Night Western Caribbean
04/04/15 - CCL Conquest: 8 Night Eastern Caribbean
02/27/15 - CCL Ecstasy: 3 Night Bahamas
01/10/15 - CCL Glory: 7 Night Eastern Caribbean

08/30/14 - CCL Breeze: 8 Night Southern Caribbean
05/18/14 - CCL Conquest: 7 Night Western Caribbean
#10
Denver, CO
576 Posts
Joined Dec 2014
Majority of my days are on Imagination. It’s a convenient itinerary in a convenient location. I’m there to relax mostly, so the ship’s attractions themselves rarely interest me.

It’s kind of nice having a home away from home.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Total Days at Sea: 44
Upcoming Days at Sea: 5

Ships Sailed:
Carnival Imagination (x4)
Carnival Inspiration
Carnival Miracle (Long Beach to Tampa Repo)
Royal Caribbean Freedom of the Seas
Disney Wonder

Upcoming Sailings:
Carnival Elation
#11
Chattanooga, TN
931 Posts
Joined May 2010
We did the same cruise on the Carnival Paradise 2 years in a row because it fit the best with school breaks. I'd go again. We've done the same itinerary from New Orleans twice as well, but the ships were different. I'm sure you'll have fun, it's a cruise after all.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Sailed:
Carnival Fascination 11/2011,Carnival Paradise 1/2013
Carnival Breeze 12/2013, Carnival Paradise 1/2014
Carnival Elation 12/2014, Norwegian Sky 10/2015
Carnival Triumph 10/2016, Carnival Fantasy 1/2018
Eurodam 9/2018
#13
Minnesota
640 Posts
Joined Mar 2015
We did the NCL Escape two years in a row. Same ports and nearly the same dates a year apart in line with Spring Break. Like others have said, we found new things to do on the ship and in port. In some respect, if you can, I think you'd be a fool not to if you left having a great time BUT I wish I'd tried that or gone there instead, etc. Three times in a row might be a bit much though.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
March 20 - Carnival Panorama (Mexican Riviera)
March 19 - MSC Seaside (Western Caribbean)
August 18 - Carnival Vista (Southern Caribbean)
March 17 - NCL Escape (Eastern Caribbean)
March 16 - NCL Escape (Eastern Caribbean)

August 02 - RCL Explorer of the Seas (Western Caribbean)
#14
Cleveland, OH
272 Posts
Joined Feb 2017
Yes, did Paradise twice. Great price at the time, loved the ship, Tampa being really easy to get to and didn't want to the Bahamas. Did Grand Cayman and Cozumel both times.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Previous and upcoming cruises:

2002 - Sovereign of the Seas
2007 - Carnival Triumph
2013 - Carnival Paradise
2015 - Carnival Paradise
2016 - Carnival Glory
2017 - Carnival Splendor
2018 - Carnival Sunshine
#16
Enosburg Falls, VT
19,986 Posts
Joined Apr 2009
If it makes sense for our schedule and budget, sure. We sailed on NCL Sky twice, in 2009 and 2010 and just finished our second cruise on Pride (first sailing was in 2012)(although we did get a new port this time on Pride since she now calls on Princess Cays).
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Previous cruises:

NCL Dream CTN May 2008
NCL Sky Bahamas April 2009 http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberre...?EntryID=54257
NCL Sky Bahamas April 2010 http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberre...?EntryID=66539
CCL Pride Bahamas October 2012 http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberre...EntryID=110323
NCL Gem Bahamas May 2014 http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberre...EntryID=255699
CCL Fascination S. Caribbean October 2016 http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberre...EntryID=551888
CCL Glory W. Caribbean November 2017 https://www.cruisecritic.com/memberr...EntryID=600224
CCL Pride Bahamas February 2018 https://www.cruisecritic.com/memberr...EntryID=612050

US Navy, too many to count but included 4 Med cruises (totaling 21 months) 1975-1992

I cruise because that's where the ocean is.

It beats haze gray and underway any day!
#17
Central NC
374 Posts
Joined Apr 2015
Pretty much all of my cruises thus far have been to the same ports of call and on the same ship (or class of ship).

I still have a good time every time.

You're in port for so little time, to us the ship is the vacation. The ports of call are just a plus. If I wanted to really visit these places, I'd fly there and stay longer than 5 hours.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Ecstasy 11/3/2018 7-Day Bermuda (Charleston)

Past Cruises
Carnival Ecstasy 5/11/2018 8-Day Eastern Caribbean (Charleston)
Carnival Sunshine 10/30/2017 5-Day Bahamas Halloween (Charleston)
Carnival Ecstasy 2/4/17 5-Day Bahamas (Charleston)
Carnival Ecstasy 4/30/16 7-Day Eastern Caribbean (Charleston)
Carnival Fantasy 12/17/14 5-Day Bahamas (Charleston)
Carnival Fantasy 4/4/14 5-Day Bahamas Carnival Live with Styx (Charleston)
#18
2,127 Posts
Joined Feb 2014
We did it! We sailed the NCL Getaway in January 2017, and fell in love in love with the ship and Freestyle Cruising, went home and booked again for the following year. We sailed it again in January 2018 with other family members along also. My next cruise is the Carnival Breeze for March 2019, and then I need to plan a family cruise for our 50th Anniversary for March 2020. Looking at the RCCL Liberty of the Seas, but if we love the Breeze, maybe we will repeat that one. I want a ship that appeals to everyone.


Sent from my iPad using Forums
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Regent Sun February 1995
Carnival Ecstasy 2/7/2000
Carnival Destiny 12/9/2001
Carnival Spirit 11/16/2002
Carnival Victory 9/6/2004
Carnival Triumph 1/6/2007
RCCL Independence of the Seas February 2014
RCCL Oasis of the Seas February 2015
NCL Getaway January 2017
NCL Getaway January 2018
Carnival Breeze March 2, 2019
Carnival Magic April 11, 2020
#19
Texas
246 Posts
Joined Feb 2012
No it's a different ship we're going on the triumph but we're getting ready to do the same ports of call and I'm thinking about changing due to we didn't really care for Yucatan Progreso
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
. o ..
o . o o.o
...oo
__[]__
__|_o_o_o\__
""""""""""/
. .. . /
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^






Rhapsody of the Seas May 2006
Carnival Fantasy June 2008 Room E122
Carnival Facsination June 2012 Room E122
#20
Oklahoma
1,574 Posts
Joined Feb 2014
Not the same itineraries, (although we wouldn't hesitate) but we've been on the Magic 3 times, the Freedom twice, and the Dream twice. We have another cruise planned on both the Magic and the Freedom. You're not crazy, go for it! Lol
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
4/6/14: Carnival Magic ~Montego Bay, Cozumel~
4/26/15: Carnival Magic ~Key West, Freeport, Nassau~
10/4/15: Carnival Magic ~Cozumel, Belize, Roatan~
1/25/16: Carnival Freedom ~Progreso, Cozumel~ Turned GOLD!
4/10/16: Carnival Splendor ~Half Moon Cay, St. Thomas, San Juan, Grand Turk~
8/28/16 Carnival Dream ~Cozumel, Costa Maya, Roatan~

2/25/17 Carnival Freedom ~Ocho Rios, Grand Cayman, Cozumel~
10/29/17 Carnival Dream ~Montego Bay, Grand Cayman, Cozumel~

Up Next:
Celebrating us both turning 40 this year with a week at Disney World followed by:



Also coming up:
Carnival Breeze 4/6/19 (Our 20th wedding anniversary cruise and 1st leg of our 1st B2B!)
Carnival Breeze 4/13/19 (2nd leg of our 1st B2B and turning PLATINUM!)
Carnival Breeze 12/28/19