sanger727 Posted August 5, 2020 #26 Share Posted August 5, 2020 I don't think that TAs booking cruises will ever disappear. Yes, I could see the cruise lines theoretically cutting TA commissions. But as pointed out, this would have to turn into the industry standard. If one cruise line decided to stop offering TA commissions then TAs would simply route their business to other cruise lines. If this were to happen then obviously TA booking perks would disappear and they would start charging fees to the consumers. For some people who see a large value to a TA due to the information and ability to fight on their behalf they may be willing to pay the fees. There could still be benefits to using a TA if they are able to get you access to a group rate that you couldn't get on your own. I sometimes use a TA and sometimes don't. I've never done business with a TA where their service was so much better than a direct booking that I would pay more to use them. If they get me a discount I use them, if they don't I direct book. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ilikeanswers Posted August 5, 2020 #27 Share Posted August 5, 2020 I don't think cruise lines will stop using TA but I do wonder if TAs that specialise in cruises only might be something that might disappear🤔. This pandemic may make TAs rethink being so narrow focused. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
drsel Posted August 5, 2020 #28 Share Posted August 5, 2020 I read on a travel agent industry magazine that for most of the main cruise lines, the commission varied from 10 to 16%, depending on the cabin category..So I assume 10% for insides, 12% for Ocean views, 14% for balconies and 16% for suites? This is applicable for the large travel agents with huge volumes Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gerryuk Posted August 5, 2020 Author #29 Share Posted August 5, 2020 Many posters are saying that cruise lines would have to employ zillions more staff if they got rid of the travel agents and the cruise lines wouldn't save any money, i don't get this. My cruise line of choice is Costa, although i am British, i live on the Spanish island of Gran Canaria. When i book a cruise online i have the choice of booking through Costas Spanish site and pay in Euros or Costas English site and pay in pound sterling. When i find the cruise i want, it takes a split second to book the room and pay online. I get a email conformation a couple of minutes later, there is no human interaction with this booking. I can then buy drinks packages and any other trimmings i want online for the cruise, again apart from me there is no human involved with this. A week or so before the cruise i get emailed all the paperwork including labels for my luggage, this is done automatically, no human is involved in this. Once on the ship the more i spend the more loyalty points i get, my points are given to me online a couple of weeks after the cruise is finished, again no human is involved with this, that's what computers are for. So i have done a couple of weeks cruising with Costa, apart from interacting with staff on the ship, i have had no other interaction with any staff on land. Of course Costa like other lines have staffed call centres where i can call if something is a miss, and of course they have I T and computer programmers to update their sites, but these staff are already in situ. If cruise lines did away with travel agents why do people seem to think that it would cost them more, as they would have to take on a army of new staff? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare LHT28 Posted August 5, 2020 #30 Share Posted August 5, 2020 10 minutes ago, drsel said: I read on a travel agent industry magazine that for most of the main cruise lines, the commission varied from 10 to 16%, depending on the cabin category.. So I assume 10% for insides, 12% for Ocean views, 14% for balconies and 16% for suites? This is applicable for the large travel agents with huge volumes Some agencies also pay a consortium to get better commission rates The rate of commission is usually the the same for insides as higher categories volume is the key 10% of $500 fare is not really much in the grand scheme as others have pointed out there are other factors taken into account so the commissionable rate my be only $300 in the end JMO Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare LHT28 Posted August 5, 2020 #31 Share Posted August 5, 2020 8 minutes ago, gerryuk said: Many posters are saying that cruise lines would have to employ zillions more staff if they got rid of the travel agents and the cruise lines wouldn't save any money, i don't get this. My cruise line of choice is Costa, although i am British, i live on the Spanish island of Gran Canaria. When i book a cruise online i have the choice of booking through Costas Spanish site and pay in Euros or Costas English site and pay in pound sterling. When i find the cruise i want, it takes a split second to book the room and pay online. I get a email conformation a couple of minutes later, there is no human interaction with this booking. I can then buy drinks packages and any other trimmings i want online for the cruise, again apart from me there is no human involved with this. A week or so before the cruise i get emailed all the paperwork including labels for my luggage, this is done automatically, no human is involved in this. So you do not think any humans input the cruises into the system or the IT dept to keep the programs up to date If you could only book online as you are proposing they would need bigger/better computer systems to handle the extra bookings good luck Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flatbush Flyer Posted August 5, 2020 #32 Share Posted August 5, 2020 37 minutes ago, drsel said: I read on a travel agent industry magazine that for most of the main cruise lines, the commission varied from 10 to 16%, depending on the cabin category.. So I assume 10% for insides, 12% for Ocean views, 14% for balconies and 16% for suites? This is applicable for the large travel agents with huge volumes Our preferred cruise line pays commissions on a sliding scale related primarily to volume of business/bookings rather by cabin category. This is one of the reasons why it is worth identifying/using top sellers of your preferred line's cruises. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sanger727 Posted August 5, 2020 #33 Share Posted August 5, 2020 29 minutes ago, gerryuk said: Many posters are saying that cruise lines would have to employ zillions more staff if they got rid of the travel agents and the cruise lines wouldn't save any money, i don't get this. My cruise line of choice is Costa, although i am British, i live on the Spanish island of Gran Canaria. When i book a cruise online i have the choice of booking through Costas Spanish site and pay in Euros or Costas English site and pay in pound sterling. When i find the cruise i want, it takes a split second to book the room and pay online. I get a email conformation a couple of minutes later, there is no human interaction with this booking. I can then buy drinks packages and any other trimmings i want online for the cruise, again apart from me there is no human involved with this. A week or so before the cruise i get emailed all the paperwork including labels for my luggage, this is done automatically, no human is involved in this. Once on the ship the more i spend the more loyalty points i get, my points are given to me online a couple of weeks after the cruise is finished, again no human is involved with this, that's what computers are for. So i have done a couple of weeks cruising with Costa, apart from interacting with staff on the ship, i have had no other interaction with any staff on land. Of course Costa like other lines have staffed call centres where i can call if something is a miss, and of course they have I T and computer programmers to update their sites, but these staff are already in situ. If cruise lines did away with travel agents why do people seem to think that it would cost them more, as they would have to take on a army of new staff? I believe the thinking is that the people who today call their TA and say that they would like to take a Caribbean cruise in May that goes to San Juan and Belize on a newer ship will now be calling the cruise line with that request. Which is a more complicated and time consuming request to find the itinerary the person is looking for and explain the room options and promo rates than simply booking a cruise. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flatbush Flyer Posted August 5, 2020 #34 Share Posted August 5, 2020 32 minutes ago, gerryuk said: Many posters are saying that cruise lines would have to employ zillions more staff if they got rid of the travel agents and the cruise lines wouldn't save any money, i don't get this. My cruise line of choice is Costa, although i am British, i live on the Spanish island of Gran Canaria. When i book a cruise online i have the choice of booking through Costas Spanish site and pay in Euros or Costas English site and pay in pound sterling. When i find the cruise i want, it takes a split second to book the room and pay online. I get a email conformation a couple of minutes later, there is no human interaction with this booking. I can then buy drinks packages and any other trimmings i want online for the cruise, again apart from me there is no human involved with this. A week or so before the cruise i get emailed all the paperwork including labels for my luggage, this is done automatically, no human is involved in this. Once on the ship the more i spend the more loyalty points i get, my points are given to me online a couple of weeks after the cruise is finished, again no human is involved with this, that's what computers are for. So i have done a couple of weeks cruising with Costa, apart from interacting with staff on the ship, i have had no other interaction with any staff on land. Of course Costa like other lines have staffed call centres where i can call if something is a miss, and of course they have I T and computer programmers to update their sites, but these staff are already in situ. If cruise lines did away with travel agents why do people seem to think that it would cost them more, as they would have to take on a army of new staff? Marketing, Advertising, Inquiries from new cruisers (who may never actually book).... Think it through! As for your "ease" of booking direct online: In a 5 minute phone call (or email) to my TA, I can do a booking, receive every available cruise line perk AND, most importantly, come away with an added TA rebate or refundable SBC of approx 10% of the commissionable fare. Thus, for a 30 day balcony cruise on Oceania, that's easily $2k in my pocket for not DIY the booking. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flatbush Flyer Posted August 5, 2020 #35 Share Posted August 5, 2020 9 minutes ago, sanger727 said: I believe the thinking is that the people who today call their TA and say that they would like to take a Caribbean cruise in May that goes to San Juan and Belize on a newer ship will now be calling the cruise line with that request. Which is a more complicated and time consuming request to find the itinerary the person is looking for and explain the room options and promo rates than simply booking a cruise. ...if they even book the cruise! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
drsel Posted August 5, 2020 #36 Share Posted August 5, 2020 Some agencies also pay a consortium to get better commission rates The rate of commission is usually the the same for insides as higher categories volume is the key 10% of $500 fare is not really much in the grand scheme as others have pointed out there are other factors taken into account so the commissionable rate my be only $300 in the end JMOThe 10 to 16% commission paid to Cruise agents is only on the base fare, excluding port fees and taxes. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gerryuk Posted August 5, 2020 Author #37 Share Posted August 5, 2020 57 minutes ago, Flatbush Flyer said: Marketing, Advertising, Inquiries from new cruisers (who may never actually book).... Think it through! All cruise lines have marketing , advertising departments and have staff to answer phone enquiries, many in different languages, nothing new there. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gerryuk Posted August 5, 2020 Author #38 Share Posted August 5, 2020 1 hour ago, Flatbush Flyer said: As for your "ease" of booking direct online: In a 5 minute phone call (or email) to my TA, I can do a booking, receive every available cruise line perk AND, most importantly, come away with an added TA rebate or refundable SBC of approx 10% of the commissionable fare. Thus, for a 30 day balcony cruise on Oceania, that's easily $2k in my pocket for not DIY the booking. Ok i take your point about perks and other posters telling us they get freebies from travel agents, but you don't get them by booking online. But hang on here a minute, who is paying for these perks?, who is paying for these freebies?, and who is paying you $2k by not booking direct? Nothing in life is free, somebody somewhere is having to pay this, freebies and perks don't grow on trees. A serious question, are those who book online and who don't use travel agents, subsidising those cruisers, who do? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
George C Posted August 5, 2020 #39 Share Posted August 5, 2020 (edited) I prefer booking straight with cruise line, we tried a agent for last cruise and they were useless. I know there are good agents out there this wasn’t one of them. Edited August 5, 2020 by George C Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flatbush Flyer Posted August 5, 2020 #40 Share Posted August 5, 2020 10 minutes ago, gerryuk said: All cruise lines have marketing , advertising departments and have staff to answer phone enquiries, many in different languages, nothing new there. What part do you not understand about the volume of inquiries now done by thousands of TAs worldwide. Are you suggesting that the phone/web inquiries alone to those TAs could be absorbed by existing staff who already have a full plate? That's naive. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flatbush Flyer Posted August 5, 2020 #41 Share Posted August 5, 2020 (edited) 8 minutes ago, gerryuk said: Ok i take your point about perks and other posters telling us they get freebies from travel agents, but you don't get them by booking online. But hang on here a minute, who is paying for these perks?, who is paying for these freebies?, and who is paying you $2k by not booking direct? Nothing in life is free, somebody somewhere is having to pay this, freebies and perks don't grow on trees. A serious question, are those who book online and who don't use travel agents, subsidising those cruisers, who do? Let's hope so! Look: no matter how you slice it or dice it- with no TA, no commission sharing. Edited August 5, 2020 by Flatbush Flyer Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare LHT28 Posted August 5, 2020 #42 Share Posted August 5, 2020 13 minutes ago, George C said: I prefer booking straight with cruise line, we tried a agent for last cruise and they were useless. Were they a true agent or an order taker? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
George C Posted August 5, 2020 #43 Share Posted August 5, 2020 2 minutes ago, LHT28 said: Were they a true agent or an order taker? They were a agent Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gerryuk Posted August 5, 2020 Author #44 Share Posted August 5, 2020 7 minutes ago, Flatbush Flyer said: What part do you not understand about the volume of inquiries now done by thousands of TAs worldwide. Are you suggesting that the phone/web inquiries alone to those TAs could be absorbed by existing staff who already have a full plate? That's naive. And many of those enquires will be sorted by your travel agent who will phone the cruise line or check the web, though. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sfaaa Posted August 5, 2020 #45 Share Posted August 5, 2020 MSC is not very keen on using TAs in N America. It seems to be getting by OK. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Charles4515 Posted August 5, 2020 #46 Share Posted August 5, 2020 Ok i take your point about perks and other posters telling us they get freebies from travel agents, but you don't get them by booking online. But hang on here a minute, who is paying for these perks?, who is paying for these freebies?, and who is paying you $2k by not booking direct? Nothing in life is free, somebody somewhere is having to pay this, freebies and perks don't grow on trees. A serious question, are those who book online and who don't use travel agents, subsidising those cruisers, who do? Why would we care? Duh.Those who could book online could use a travel agent. But those who use travel agents are not subsidizing those who book online. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare aungrl Posted August 5, 2020 #47 Share Posted August 5, 2020 4 hours ago, gerryuk said: Ok i take your point about perks and other posters telling us they get freebies from travel agents, but you don't get them by booking online. But hang on here a minute, who is paying for these perks?, who is paying for these freebies?, and who is paying you $2k by not booking direct? Nothing in life is free, somebody somewhere is having to pay this, freebies and perks don't grow on trees. A serious question, are those who book online and who don't use travel agents, subsidising those cruisers, who do? You might want to take a look at CruiseTruth.com. The site is focused on luxury cruising/travel, but a lot of the information is applicable to cruising in general. That site would suggest that yes, most definitely, anyone booking direct with the cruise line means the cruise line doesn't pay a commission on that booking, so those individuals are at least indirectly subsidizing others who use a TA and for whom the cruise line has to pay the commission. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rkacruiser Posted August 5, 2020 #48 Share Posted August 5, 2020 This is an interesting thread to read. Lots of good posts on both sides of the issue. I know the benefits that I have received by using a travel agent for my cruise bookings. Some travel agents offer more than others as I have discovered. Those good people, working within the confines of their organization's policies for the cruise(s) that I want to book, that are not able to match the benefits/pricing/perks of another agency: I don't blame. They are doing the best that they can! (And, I have seen that more than once.) What "slice of the pie" that I pay for a cruise my travel agent receives is of no concern for me. What I am concerned about is a reservation that is accurately made, with help quickly available if issues arise and changes to the reservation need to be made, and an ombudsman type person to properly represent me with those issues. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lenquixote66 Posted August 6, 2020 #49 Share Posted August 6, 2020 My former TA gave gifts.For the first cruise booked a canvas bag.For the second cruise booked a quality pair of binoculars.For our third cruise with her a carryon . Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
donaldsc Posted August 6, 2020 #50 Share Posted August 6, 2020 11 hours ago, gerryuk said: Ok i take your point about perks and other posters telling us they get freebies from travel agents, but you don't get them by booking online. But hang on here a minute, who is paying for these perks?, who is paying for these freebies?, and who is paying you $2k by not booking direct? Nothing in life is free, somebody somewhere is having to pay this, freebies and perks don't grow on trees. A serious question, are those who book online and who don't use travel agents, subsidising those cruisers, who do? I don't much care if the on line bookers are subsidizing my perks. That is their problem and not mine. You can use the same logic for people who buy stuff using coupons or stuff on sale or even people who do not believe in taking uneaten food from a restaurant in a doggy bag. DON 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now